Being a three-sport standout in high school today isn’t as common today as it used to be. Time was, student-athletes could jump straight from the gridiron to the basketball court to the baseball diamond and excel almost immediately.
In those cases, natural talent simply took over.
The explosion of offseason training and the focus on year-round club sports has diminished that, by a lot. As the athletes improve, natural talent begins to mean less and less. In many situations, the hard work kids do in the offseason to improve their sport-specific skill set can override natural talents.
That’s why far more athletes are choosing to dedicate themselves to a single sport at an early age, having bought into the club coaches mantra of, “if you’re not training all year for (sport X) you’re falling behind, because your competition is.”
While there may be a shred of truth in that, the overarching reason for saying it is rooted in dollars, not sense. Year-round single sport facilities are money makers for those who run them, so the more kids that stay locked in on a single sport all year, the more money that facility and its owners bring in. And while it’s probably true that kids who spend all their time focusing on one sport do make skill-specific improvements, their “competition” isn’t the actual issue. At the high school level, the only real competition for athletes in the off season is with themselves. And the benefits of being a multi-sport athlete, which are very well documented, far outweigh the negatives of missing single sport training time in that regard.
So as a coach, how can you balance your need to improve sports-specific skill sets during the offseason with allowing and encouraging your players to become better all-around athletes by playing multiple sports?
Fall sports coaches have an advantage here, given the two plus months ramp up period they have during the summer. Football coaches, for example, can do conditioning, seven-on-sevens, and team camps with their players over the summer to make sure their football players are ready when week one arrives. All the while, football players can participate in summer baseball and basketball while still having ample opportunity to get ready for the rapidly approaching football season.
Winter sports get a shorter ramp up period, typically a couple of weeks in most cases. While it might be tough to get football or soccer players to find the time to get shots up in the gym prior to the start of basketball season, once fall sports end there is still time to get those fall sports athletes up to speed. A good winter sports coach will find the time, and encourage his fall sports kids to use the gym as their time allows, without pressuring them to be at all the team “open gym” sessions.
Spring sports coaches have it the most difficult. That’s because the conclusion of winter sports season most often overlaps with the start of spring sports. There’s little or no ramp up time. In baseball, we worry about arm conditioning and the prevention of early season issues with athletes who are probably in great physical condition overall, but who may have done little to no throwing over the course of the fall and winter sport season. Jumping straight off the wrestling mat or the basketball court directly onto a pitching mound, for example, is a recipe for dead arm and even elbow surgery.
Once again, it’s up to the coaches to find a way to get arm conditioning and strength work in with players/pitchers when the time is convenient for the player, regardless of when the full team is working out. With the availability of indoor hitting facilities growing every year, those who want to get their swings in right before the start of the season have that opportunity if they’re willing to work some overtime.
Kids who play basketball and then join the track team may actually need some time off their feet, with injuries like shin splints being a real concern.
It’s up to the coach to work directly with each individual multi-sport athlete to create a plan that best allows that player to A) stay on course academically, B) not detract from that athlete’s in-season sport and C) find time to do the type of workouts and conditioning that allows that player to shift from one sport to another without jeopardizing the athlete’s health and well-being.
High school needs more multi-sport athletes, not less. It’s up to the high school coaches to step in and show their athletes how it’s possible to excel in more than one sport.