CONIFER — There was a ton on the line Friday night at Fitzmaurice Field on the campus of Conifer High School.
Mountain Bowl trophy, Class 3A Foothills League title, not to mention bragging rights for the next year for whoever came up on top in the 18th annual showdown rivalry between the Evergreen Cougars and Conifer Lobos.
“This is what the Mountain Bowl is supposed to be like,” Evergreen coach Matthew Van Praag said of the Class 3A top-10 match-up of the to squad that came in with a combined 15 wins and 1 loss. “That is why this is the best rivalry in the state. These kids know each other and play hard. We’ve got good football up here.”
In one of the wildest ending of the rivalry, the Cougars escaped by the skin of their teeth with a 16-14 victory.

Dennis Pleuss/Jeffco Public Schools
“That was so scary. I’ve never been more scared in my life,” Evergreen junior quarterback Tom Van Den Bos said of watching the Lobos’ final drive from the sidelines. “We thought they would easily get a field goal, but they had no timeouts left. I don’t really know what was going on over there.”
Conifer (7-2 record, 3-2) had the ball on its own 25-yard line with 2:15 left in the fourth quarter with Evergreen (9-0, 5-0) holding a slim 16-14 lead. The Lobos converted a couple of big third-down plays and a huge 17-yard run by junior quarterback Charlie Ostrowski got Conifer down to Evergreen’s 6-yard line with 14 seconds to play and the Lobos took their final timeout.
Conifer coach Matt Steinfeldt talked about the plan in the final seconds. He wanted to center the ball to the middle of the field for freshman kicker Brylan Hogzett and spike the ball to stop the clock to set up a potential game-winning field goal.
The problem, a holding call on the play where Ostrowski got to the middle of the field and gave himself up put the ball on the 16-yard line with 11 seconds to play. Steinfeldt then felt like a 30-plus yard field goal was probably out of Hogzett’s range.
On the final snap, Ostrowski couldn’t handle the snap and several Conifer and Evergreen players jumped on the dogpile going for the loose ball. Eventually the clock expired. Evergreen’s sideline and student section stormed the field as Conifer players and coaches were left stunned.
“In hindsight, it was bad coaching on my part,” Steinfeldt admitted of the final couple plays. “We had a plan and thought process of what we wanted to do.”
It was really the first really close game for the undefeated Cougars, who were not only able to celebrate winning the Mountain Bowl trophy back for the first time since 2022 but were also awarded the 3A Foothills championship plaque.
“We had a lot going against us. The whole team has the flu,” said Van Praag, who added that the Cougars were very depleted at the receiver position. “Man, just a big gusty win for this program. I’m so proud of them.”
Evergreen got out to a 10-0 lead in the first half. Senior Grady White scored on a 2-yard touchdown run on the Cougars’ opening possession. Senior James Mauro then came up with the biggest hit of the night jarring the ball loose from Conifer running back Mckade Tracy.

Dennis Pleuss/Jeffco Public Schools
“That was their option and we’ve been practicing that all week,” Mauro said of his big hit on Tracy after he received the pitch. “My job is the option guy. I knew I had to blow him up there.”
Evergreen freshman Tristan Carter recovered the fumble. The Cougars would cash in the turnover with a 35-yard field goal by junior Karrik Boyle to give Evergreen a 10-0 lead.
“James was a captain for us as a freshman,” Van Praag said of Mauro. “He has just plugged along, plugged along. He makes plays for us all over the field. He is just a stud.”
Mauro came up with the biggest defensive play of the game scooping up a fumble by the Lobos and returning it for a 16-yard touchdown with 2:02 left in the third quarter to give the Cougars a 16-7 lead.
“That touchdown felt so good,” Mauro said of providing the Cougars their lone score in the second half. “I had to pick it up and go score.”
Conifer did fight back in the fourth quarter. Ostrowski threw his second touchdown of the game early in the fourth quarter. The 8-yard touchdown pass to senior Liam Van Airsdale gave Conifer life to retain the Mountain Bowl trophy.
However, Conifer would had to give up the coveted trophy for at least 365 days.
“Despite us being on the losing end of it, I think we both gave a very good Mountain Bowl for everyone to enjoy,” Steinfeldt said. “Everyone got their money’s worth.”
Conifer closes out its regular season on the road against Green Mountain (3-6, 2-3) at 7 p.m. Friday, Oct. 30, at Trailblazer Stadium in Lakewood.
“Being a 7-2 (record) at this part of the season we feel like we can bounce back next week and get a first-round home game, probably,” Steinfeldt said of putting the bitter loss behind the Lobos.
Evergreen wraps up its regular season on the road against Kent Denver (3-6, 2-3) at 1 p.m. Saturday, Oct. 31.
“We have to keep rolling into the playoffs. We get to host now,” Mauro said of Evergreen likely having a top-8 seed and first-round bye before hosting a second-round game. “It is the first league championship in a while. It’s huge.”
Evergreen last won a conference football title was over a decade ago in 2015.

Dennis Pleuss/Jeffco Public Schools